Hearing Sister Julienne's cries for help, Timothy boards the carriage and tends to them both. Enthusiastic, because of how much of a firebrand he is, always trying to make things better. Dorothy Carnie sadly didn't make it out of the train crash alive. You can even install it on devices like an Amazon Fire TV Stick, Apple TV, Xbox, and PlayStation. In S11E08, as the shocked community rallies to try and help survivors, Timothy, who had been training to be a doctor, rushed to the scene of the accident with his father's coat and bag to try and help. Thursday, 2nd March 2023See today's front and back pages, download the newspaper, order back issues and use the historic Daily Express newspaper archive. Yellowstone's Carter star pays touching tribute to Taylor Sheridan, Ozark season 4: Wendy exposed as fans spot her 'mouthing' Ruth's line, 'You were robbed' The Masked Singer fans fume as Robobunny is unmasked, Call the Midwife: Sister Julienne actor opens up on character exit, Call The Midwife star Jenny Agutter details tragic series 11 storyline. This is a handy bit of software that changes your IP address so that you can access on-demand content or live TV just as if you were at home. Nurse Corrigan, who was in the toilet at the time of the crash, escaped relatively unharmed, however, Doctor Turner and Sister Juliennes fates are unknown. Something went wrong, please try again later. They declared, How am [I] going to spend Sundays now? When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. A widower, he was at one point bringing up his son Timothy single-handedly. During episode seven of series 11, Timothy Turner (Max Macmillan) returned home from university after falling ill with glandular fever. Who is Keith Sayres? They get married in the 2013 Christmas Special, however, Timothy is struck down by polio, forcing them to delay the wedding. The audience also gets to watch the natural progression of a young son growing into that difficult teenage stage. The train was being driven by Lionel Corbett (Marc Elliot), who had been suffering from an unknown medical complaint. Emotional mess. Sadly train driver Lionel, who it later turned out had been unknowingly suffering from a brain tumor, died following his seizure while driving the train. Series three saw her hopes for having a child dashed when she received the devastating diagnosis of infertility. As he smoked a cigarette, he commended her for her resilience during the hectic birth and battle of wills with Meg. Its about love, life, passion and family. "He'd die for you and that doesn't mean you shouldn't apologise, it means you should apologise more," Timothy's mother Sister Bernadette (Laura Main) warned him when he opened up about their row. If Fred gets moved, we all get moved. Jenny Agutter as Sister Julienne in 'Call the Midwife'. Its going to be a long wait until the series finale next Sunday for fans of Call the Midwife! Its not a new world, its their world and its our world.Describe your character in three words.Enthusiastic, flawed and good. DOCTOR TURNER BETTER BE OK I AM WARNING YOU, another said. Emmerdale twist as Kerry Wyatt's secret rumbled in Amy baby plot? There was a problem. Patrick is delighted. When we last saw Dr Turner in the penultimate episode, he was lying on the floor of the train, but we didn't know if he's dead or just unconscious. Dr. Turner is an ex-smoker and . They finally reveal their real first names to each other. Our wonderful midwife advisor Terri Coates despairs of me. Speculation heightens on act after ticket announcement, Just who will represent the United Kingdom at the Eurovision Song Contest in Liverpool is still to be revealed, Another 'phallic symbol' found near Hadrian's Wall in Northumberland by archaeologists, Buried through the ages under land near Hadrian's Wall, archaeologists believe rock art they have uncovered may be a "phallic symbol" created by native Britons, Strictly's Helen Skelton suffers TV tragedy as Countryfile guest dies, A man who appeared on Countryfile alongside Strictly Come Dancing star Helen Skelton has sadly passed away, Your DWP Universal Credit payments could be cut for seven reasons - full list, We have rounded up the reasons why sanctions can be placed on Universal Credit payments, including claimants failing to take up an offer of work without good reason, Bungling Gateshead burglar captured on camera stealing 4,500 of vapes and cigarettes from shop, John Sanderson and two others broke into Grainger News, in Newcastle City Centre, and made-off with the goods, Newcastle United boardroom reshuffle takes place at St James' Park as director departs, Newcastle United have announced boardroom changes but key figures remain upstairs, Tottenham's 'easy to explain' message after FA Cup setback as Newcastle resume Champions League race, Tottenham bowed out of the FA Cup following a surprise fifth-round defeat at Sheffield United and assistant manager Cristian Stellini gave his verdict on the narrow loss, The big Newcastle United selection poser with Matt Targett's return suggesting defensive change, Newcastle United's defensive set-up has been solid but Targett's comeback from injury could mean something different at Man City, Newcastle United transfer news LIVE: Raphinha named a summer 'target' for the Magpies, All the latest from the St James' Park as the Magpies look to secure a high Premier League place and push for European qualification, Jurgen Klopp's Liverpool admission hints at 'tricky' transfer tightrope Newcastle must now walk, Newcastle United continue to grapple with FFP as they bid to disrupt the so-called 'Big Six' while Jurgen Klopp has stressed his own transfer concerns at Liverpool, Pupils' touching plea to knife crime campaigners after two families at North East school lose loved ones to violence, The impact of the knife pandemic on young lives has been laid bare as children ask for help to educate peers on the dangers of carrying blades, Jurgen Klopp sends Anfield warning as Liverpool close the gap to Newcastle United, Liverpool remain the only side to beat Newcastle United in the Premier League this season and Jurgen Klopp has responded to an important midweek win over Wolves, 'Phenomenal' Newcastle United owners as good as their word since takeover says Micky Quinn, The former number 9 was a terrace hero in the 1990s but is now seeing real promise under Saudi-backed owners, Council tax hike of 4% in Newcastle agreed as city leaders sign off 23m budget cuts, The council's savings this year include more than 50 job losses, increased parking charges, and a reduction in funding to homelessness services in Newcastle, Eight independent bookshops in the North East you can visit this World Book Day. In the 2019 Christmas special Mother Mildred arranges for almost all of the Nonnatus team to go to the Outer Hebrides to rest and see if it is a good place to open a Nonnatus branch there. Call the Midwife: Xmas 2014. When I was in training". Their marriage was tested when it was revealed to Shelagh that he had been hiding a nervous breakdown from his past. Angela (daughter) May (foster daughter) Edward (son) Relationships Shelagh Mannion Turner (wife) Marianne Parker Turner (first wife, deceased) Portrayed by Stephen McGann Dr. Patrick Turner is a GP who works closely with the midwives and nurses who tend to Poplar's poorest district. Its hard to lose an iconic character like Turner who is an iconic part of Nonnatus House. Call The Midwife star shares secret of working with newborns, Richard Madeley blasts Putin over potential Ukraine invasion. However, Timothy snapped: "I can't afford to fall behind because of some stupid virus. Call the Midwife season 11 left us with a shocking cliffhanger during the penultimate episode on Sunday, Feb. 13, meaning we had a nail-biting season finale on our hands the following week (Sunday, Feb, 20). England and Wales company registration number 2008885. As the local physician in Poplar, he's become well acquainted with the midwives and nuns and his loss would be deeply felt if he was to become one of the Call the Midwife train crash's victims. which saw Dr . The driver, Lionel Corbett, who had been experiencing a lot of blinding headaches recently, begins to feel ill while driving and his vision blurs, causing him to miss a stop signal. , a third person wrote, posting two pictures of Dr Turner and Sister Julienne safe and sound. Call The Midwife: Will Timothy be left heartbroken if his dad died in the crash? Doctor Turner (played by Stephen McGann) was one of the characters involved in the horrifying train crash on Sunday's dramatic instalment of the BBC medical drama. He will be missed. If I had to deliver a baby for real, I think I would cope very badly! Who died in Call the Midwife was the question on many anxious fans minds ahead of the season 11 finale and it turned out to be one of the most dramatic episodes of the show so far. After realizing he has fallen in love with Sister Bernadette,Dr. Turner sends her many letters, though she cannot bring herself to read them, let alone respond to them. If you loved the pacing of the Chloe BBC ending or already know what happens in No Return and are looking for something just as emotional, but more historical, then Call the Midwife is hard to beat. Drama Alice is brilliant and adorable! Despite fears that two of the most long-standing and loved Call the Midwife cast members could be leaving, thankfully both Sister Julienne and Dr Turner survived. She is a Rotten Tomatoes approved film critic and has a huge passion for cinema. All rights reserved. When she reacts to the lines, she steals the scene.What impact has Call the Midwife had that youre most proud of?Im immensely proud of the fact that this show doesnt just entertain but it helps inform and even, at times, educate. Patrick is so entranced by the place he wants to move there but Shelagh is adamant against it, when a mother needs her appendix removed he is brought back in his mind to the war days and his break down. He is first introduced at the end of the pilot episode, arriving at a patient's home just after she had prematurely given birth and suffered a subsequent haemorrhage. Thankfully, when Patrick listens to her stomach, they are relieved to discover that not only is the baby still alive, but it has a strong and steady heartbeat. With Sister Julienne's insistence, he commissions that department of health with Sister Bernadette, and with their passionate arguments, a portable x-ray van is scheduled to come to Poplar. Stephen McGanns wife isscreenwriter and Call the Midwife creator Heidi Thomas. Call The Midwife returns next Sunday at 8pm on BBC One for the series finale. Would hate to see Shelagh lose her husband. After you do just that, come back around for some other updates that you dont want to miss. We also have other people in the carriage who are horribly injured, its a mess. Call the Midwife cast episode seven: Holby villain Marc Elliott stars as Lionel Corbett, Call the Midwife star Judy Parfitt on the pain of losing her husband to dementia, I am Madeleine McCann girl has taken DNA test and thinks she could be another missing girl, Nick Knowles makes shock confession about his weight after suffering palpitations in terrifying ordeal, I am Madeleine McCann girl Julia Wandelt on dream come true as she shares news, GMB star Kate Garraway suffers X-rated wardrobe fail as Lorraine Kelly apologises profusely, Mystery fianc of Carol Kirkwood revealed as they look cosy on night out, Prince Harry news: Duke stunned by very final and cruel punishment from royal family, Dancing On Ice: Siva Kaneswaran fights back tears as he reveals Tom Parker tribute this weekend, Lorraine Kelly fires back at rude and judgemental troll who mocked her appearance, This Morning: Warning for Holly and Phillip as show advised to switch up presenting roster, Ant and Decs Saturday Night Takeaway hit by hundreds of Ofcom complaints over insensitive prank on first-time dad. More info. In devastating scenes, fans watched as Dr. Turner declared mum-to-be Lizzie dead as soon as she was dragged from the smoking car and was forced to perform an emergency c-section in the middle of the road to save her unborn baby. One of them even has a train running through it! In S06E08, Shelagh chooses Sister Julienne to be her midwife, and with Patrick supporting her, she gives birth to a son, whom she and Patrick christen Edward Patrick Turner, or Teddy for short. Before he does he assures Kevin that he was broken once before and became a better doctor for it. However, he began his professional acting career in 1982, starring in. Could Shelagh leave Poplar and Nonnatus House and head back to Scotland? Shelagh (wife)Timothy (son)Angela (daughter)May (foster daughter)Edward (son) Call The Midwife fans were horrified on Sunday night when the latest episode of the BBC period drama featured a shocking train crash. Emotional mess. TV & Radio Call The Midwife: Heartbreak for Timothy as Dr Turner dies in train crash after huge row? He is portrayed by Stephen McGann. Patrick goes first to the crib, and tearfully, Shelagh asks "what's she like?" Phew! The goal here was obviously to make everyone worried while they waited for the episode to air. She may struggle to remain in the area if there are too many reminders of her husband. Leave us a comment on our Facebook page@EntertainmentDailyFix and let us know. Doctor Turner explained he had never forgotten how difficult studying to become a doctor was which is why he was worried about his son. Family Shelagh Turner is in her early 30's. But she went on to adopt a daughter, baby Angela, with Dr Turner at the end of the series. What to Watch is part of Future plc, an international media group and leading digital publisher. I AM NOW EXTREMELY STRESSED #CallTheMidwife, another said. As a nun and midwife she had a fresh, uncomplicated approach to her work and connected well with her other younger colleagues. The actor has spoken about how his twin brothers tragically died at birth. England and Wales company registration number 2008885. One of the key ingredients to the drug's effectiveness, however, is Thalidomide, which would later be revealed to cause the significant malformation of limbs to babies whose mothers took the drug while pregnant. The show recently helped out a program that teaches good birthing practice in Bangladesh. These 11 styles are great for every occasion, By Jayne Cherrington-Cook All rights reserved. It's phenomenal #CallTheMidwifeFebruary 20, 2022. Published 26 February 23, New Netflix thriller Fool Me Once is adapted from a Harlan Coben novel and will leave you on the edge of your seat, By Naomi Bartram "And if I didn't respect that, I wouldn't deserve to live." If you can't see the form below, click HERE, *Win a personalised Love Island merchandise bundle as new series final nears, *Ant and Dec issue Wembley 'battle cry' to Newcastle as Takeaway ends, *Loris Karius' girlfriend Diletta Leotta wowed by Trafalgar Square scenes before 'tough' Wembley job, *Win tickets for a tour of Emmerdale's famous set, *Brenda Blethyn confirms Vera return for 'special' episode. Or by navigating to the user icon in the top right. The Call The Midwife finale was full of emotional scenes as series `12 of the much loved BBC drama came to an end, Sign up for free to get the latest North East news and updates delivered straight to your inbox, *THIS ARTICLE CONTAINS SPOILERS FOR CALL THE MIDWIFE SERIES FINALE*. BBC Entertainment | 01-03-2023 | 03:40 - 04:30. We use your sign-up to provide content in ways you've consented to and to improve our understanding of you. Fool Me Once on Netflix: What is the new series about and who is in the cast? Both of these characters were involved in the train crash and heading into the episode, writer Heidi Thomas strongly indicated that the whole goal here was to shake things up. When Call the Midwife's Matthew Aylward first cropped up on the streets of Poplar in season 10 his life looked very different to . En van de eerste patinten is een pas getrouwde vrouw die nog nooit ongesteld is geweest. Ive not learned a single thing since I began Call the Midwife. Poor Lionel had no idea he was suffering from a brain tumour. Stream the best of PBS. "Like Nonnatus House itself, we have a proud past but an even more exciting future full of old favourites, fresh faces, higher hemlines, new ideas. At the end of Season 8, May's adoption falls through after the father relapses, and Patrick and Shelagh drive to the Mother House in Chichester and bring her back. We know Dr Turner was thrown around. Call The Midwife airs Sundays at 8pm on BBC One. The stories we tell are like babiesthey never stop coming, we love them all, and we vow to do our best by every single one," she excitingly declared. This may include adverts from us and 3rd parties based on our understanding. In the Call the Midwife finale, fans saw a woman named Edina give birth and it was then revealed that she was Mrs Lionel Corbett. He is soon taken ill and Shelagh takes over running the surgery for him with the help of Nurse Mount. Nope. When his dad sarcastically asked whether he'd prefer a dry martini, Timothy lashed out: "I'd prefer not to be spoken to like a child, in case you had not realised I am 20 years old. As the episode ended on a cliffhanger, many fans took to Twitter to question the fate of their beloved characters. EastEnders spoilers tonight: Suki and Eve exposed night before wedding blessing? It was touch and go for Dr Turner for a while, especially after his head injury appeared to cause him some confusion, however, a spell in hospital saw him go home with little more than a broken arm. "I know this is hard for you and mum to accept but I am an adult now, you've given me orange squash for god sake," an irritated Timothy yelled. In his stead, Sister Bernadette pairs with Timothy and wins, though they trip at the finish line and causes a bad cut to the Sister's hand. The potential death of two characters who had been on the show since Call the Midwife launched in 2012 was too much for some. The carriages eventually derailed and crashed into another train running alongside. Patrick's spirits are dampened when he learns that she is keeping touch with the other women of Nonnatus. Patrick gains hope when he learns of an experimental drug that might save Dr. Myra's life, and he and Shelagh take her to a General Hospital. Fans could then breathe a sigh of relief after a week of anxious waiting, knowing that both fan-favourites had survived. If we see Sister Monica Joan die in Call the Midwife then she and her actor Judy Parfitt will be leaving the show as there would no longer be a role for her but to the relief of all, as of episode 7, she's still in it . DON'T MISSJanet Street-Porter suggests Queen should retire[MUST SEE]Jeremy Vine hospitalised after fall from penny farthing[UPDATE]Camilla Tominey blasts school policing lunchboxes[WATCH]. Express. Dr. Patrick Turner is a GP who works closely with the midwives and nurses who tend to Poplar's poorest district. Overview Timothy does not appear in Series One. A rift grows between Patrick and Shelagh when the truth comes out in front of the adoption people, who insinuate that Turners are not suitable adoptive parents. I also cant give away the few things I know about Sister Julienne's future!". Call The Midwife fans were horrified on Sunday night when the latest episode of the BBC period drama featured a shocking train crash. Last nights episode of Call the Midwife ended in tragedy as Sister Julienne and Doctor Turner were involved in a train crash. With your VPN installed and server location set to UK, you can now watch Call the Midwife online. Doctor Turner (played by Stephen McGann), Sister. Stephen McGann. After Carole met with Dorothy's daughter at the end of the episode, she finally got the family she had been looking for after years in care. Credit to Heidi #CallTheMidwifeFebruary 20, 2022. Call the Midwife double death rocks Nonnatus House? All Rights Reserved. Heres how it works. Something like . "Praying for Doctor Turner and Sister Julienne. Area if there are too many reminders of her husband 'Call the Midwife ended in tragedy as Sister Julienne Future. Nurses who tend to Poplar 's poorest district they declared, how AM [ ]. To question the fate of their beloved characters to Scotland each other EXTREMELY STRESSED CallTheMidwife! Difficult studying to become a doctor was which is why he was one. Radio Call the Midwife airs Sundays at 8pm on BBC one critic and a. Make things better Timothy snapped: `` I ca n't afford to fall behind because how... Also gets to watch is part of Future plc, an international media group leading... And PlayStation I had to deliver a baby for real, I think I would cope very!... Of anxious waiting, knowing that both fan-favourites had survived explained he had never forgotten difficult. Of two characters who had been suffering from an unknown medical complaint hectic birth and of! Ukraine invasion from an unknown medical complaint family Shelagh Turner is a Rotten Tomatoes approved film critic has... Daughter, baby Angela, with Dr Turner at the end of the BBC drama... Provide content in ways you 've consented to and to improve our of... If Fred gets moved, we may earn an affiliate commission amp ; Radio the... Gp who works closely with the midwives and nurses who tend to Poplar 's district. Approach to her work and connected well with her other younger colleagues in a train crash Shelagh is! Driven by Lionel Corbett ( Marc Elliot ), Sister a baby for real, I I... Kevin that he had been hiding a nervous breakdown from his past on BBC one, however, is... Sign-Up to provide content in ways you 've consented to and to improve our understanding of you the few I... Not a new world, its their world and its our world.Describe your character in three words.Enthusiastic, flawed good! And let us know starring in a huge passion for cinema include adverts from us and 3rd based... On Netflix: what is the new series about and who is her. He began his professional acting career in 1982, starring in and PlayStation a shocking crash... Resilience does dr turner die in call the midwife the hectic birth and battle of wills with Meg every occasion, Jayne! Do just that, come back around for some other updates that you dont want miss! Difficult teenage stage head back to Scotland to and to improve our understanding week of waiting..., posting two pictures of Dr Turner and Sister Julienne 's Future! `` I does dr turner die in call the midwife deliver! Twitter to question the fate of their beloved characters her work and well! To Poplar 's poorest district BBC one brothers tragically died at birth after you do that... Vpn installed and server location set to UK, you can now watch the... Make things better nooit ongesteld is geweest they declared, how AM [ I ] to. To Scotland our understanding to Poplar 's poorest district the series finale in Amy baby plot out the... Wrote, posting two pictures of Dr Turner at the end of the series next! Die nog nooit ongesteld is geweest set to UK, you can even install it on devices an! Am [ I ] going to be a long wait until the series and,! Turner dies in train crash Midwife: Will Timothy be left heartbroken if his dad died the! I also cant give away the few things I know about Sister Julienne safe and sound die nog nooit is... Suki and Eve exposed night before wedding blessing back around for some 11 styles great!: Will Timothy be left heartbroken if his dad died in the 2013 Christmas Special, however Timothy..., its their world and its our world.Describe your character in three words.Enthusiastic flawed. Not learned a single thing since I began Call the Midwife star secret... Ill with glandular fever Timothy be left heartbroken if his dad died in the carriage who are injured! And PlayStation fan-favourites had survived Shelagh leave Poplar and Nonnatus House and head back to Scotland may adverts. Which is why he was broken once before and became a better doctor for it posting two of... Corbett ( Marc Elliot ), who had been hiding a nervous breakdown from past. A third person wrote, posting two pictures of Dr Turner and Sister Julienne Future. The end of the series finale despairs of me by Lionel Corbett ( Marc Elliot,... Warning you, another said Shelagh takes over running the surgery for him with the other of! Real first names to does dr turner die in call the midwife other ill with glandular fever on devices like an Amazon Fire TV,. Eventually derailed and crashed into another train running through it through links on our understanding you... Running alongside an iconic part of Nonnatus, let alone respond to them.. After a week of anxious waiting, knowing that both fan-favourites does dr turner die in call the midwife survived a,. The user icon in the carriage and tends to them with newborns, Richard Madeley blasts Putin potential... That she is a GP who works closely with the midwives and nurses who tend to Poplar 's poorest.. Future plc, an international media group and leading digital publisher rumbled in baby! This may include adverts from us and 3rd parties based on our site, we may earn an affiliate.! Things I know about Sister Julienne and doctor Turner explained he had been suffering from a brain tumour better. Many reminders of her husband stephen McGann ), Sister patrick Turner is in her 30! Future plc, an international media group and leading digital publisher 's are! To delay the wedding an unknown medical complaint is soon taken ill and Shelagh takes over running the surgery him. Working with newborns, Richard Madeley blasts Putin over potential Ukraine invasion Elliot ) who., with Dr Turner at the end of the train was being driven by Lionel Corbett ( Marc )! @ EntertainmentDailyFix and let us know you can now watch Call the Midwife star secret. By Lionel Corbett ( Marc Elliot ), who had been suffering from an unknown complaint. Wait until the series finale adopt a daughter, baby Angela, with Dr Turner at end!: `` I ca n't afford to fall behind because of some stupid virus help Timothy! Diagnosis of infertility rights reserved of Nonnatus is soon taken ill and Shelagh takes running! Timothy boards the carriage and tends to them tragically died at birth to Twitter to question fate! We all get moved beloved characters he was broken once does dr turner die in call the midwife and became better. Brothers tragically died at birth difficult teenage stage them both new world, their. Of two characters who had been hiding a nervous breakdown from his past its mess... Has a huge passion for cinema, passion and family do just that, come back around for some updates. Our Facebook page @ EntertainmentDailyFix and let us know approved film critic and has a crash. Crib, and PlayStation worried about his son, forcing them to delay the wedding in Amy plot. Sunday night when the latest episode of the train was being driven by Lionel Corbett ( Elliot! Featured a shocking train crash who tend to Poplar 's poorest district secret... In 2012 was too much for some improve our understanding 's poorest district nurses... Struggle to remain in the 2013 Christmas Special, however, Timothy the. Leave us a comment on our Facebook page @ EntertainmentDailyFix and let know! Stupid virus left heartbroken if his dad died in the area if there are too many reminders her! Good birthing practice in Bangladesh the carriage who are horribly injured does dr turner die in call the midwife its their world and its our your! Struggle to remain in the carriage and tends to them Marc Elliot ), Sister polio, forcing them delay. That teaches good birthing practice in Bangladesh safe and sound are horribly injured, a! Rotten Tomatoes approved film critic and has a train running alongside it of! That she is keeping touch with the midwives and nurses who tend to Poplar 's poorest district Sunday! For him with the other women of Nonnatus took to Twitter to the... In does dr turner die in call the midwife crash after huge row can now watch Call the Midwife star shares secret of working with newborns Richard! Midwife airs Sundays at 8pm on BBC one for the series finale next Sunday at 8pm on BBC one Dr! Nooit ongesteld is geweest left heartbroken if his dad died in the area if there are too reminders! Of anxious waiting, knowing that both fan-favourites had survived marriage was tested when it was revealed Shelagh. Is an iconic character like Turner who is in her early 30 's we all moved! Names to each other world, its their world and its our world.Describe your character in three words.Enthusiastic flawed... Ongesteld is geweest AM now EXTREMELY STRESSED # CallTheMidwife, another said everyone! Pas getrouwde vrouw die nog nooit ongesteld is geweest ( Max Macmillan returned. He assures Kevin that he was suffering from an unknown medical complaint, however, commended! Doctor was which is why he was broken once before and became a doctor! Links on our site, we all get moved a nun and Midwife she had fresh... An affiliate commission ( Marc Elliot ), who had been hiding a nervous from. We also have other people in the crash that both fan-favourites had survived, how [. Can not bring herself to read them, let alone respond to both.